Selective Writing Exam: How to Plan a 25/25 Creative Piece
Nelson's personal tips to help students plan a full mark creative writing piece for the NSW Selective Test.
Author: Nelson Luo (Founder & Principal)
- Ex-North Sydney Boys (Rank 1st NSW)
- 98.20 ATAR (Australia's Top 2% )
- 100% UNSW Co-Op Scholarship Recipient
- Student Mentor of 100+ students
I've seen it hundreds of times. Students sit down for their Selective Test writing task, read the prompt, and immediately start planning an elaborate story with a clear beginning, middle, and end.
They envision complex plot twists, multiple character arcs, rising action, climax, and a satisfying resolution.
They spend precious minutes mapping out an entire adventure, trying to squeeze a complete narrative journey into just 400 words.
And the result is that their writing feels rushed, surface-level, and forgettable.
These students aren't lacking creativity or writing ability. They're operating under a fundamental misconception about what makes creative writing exceptional.
When I was preparing for my HSC English Advanced Module C, I had this same problem. My creative pieces felt like summaries rather than stories. My English teacher pulled me aside one afternoon and said something that completely transformed my approach:
"Stop trying to tell a whole story. Capture a single moment instead."
At first, I didn't understand. How could a single moment be more powerful than an entire story? Wouldn't that be boring? Incomplete?
But then I started looking at creative writing that actually scored full marks. I asked top students in the grade above me for their creative pieces. I asked my tutor for their pieces. And I studied them.
They all had something in common. Instead of telling a full story, they all zoomed into one culturally or emotionally significant moment and explored it with extraordinary depth and detail.
This insight absolutely changed the game for my English results.
Think about your own life for a second. When you remember important experiences, do you recall the entire day from start to finish? Or do you remember specific moments with vivid clarity?
That moment when you heard difficult news and the world seemed to stop. The instant you achieved something you'd worked toward for years. The second you realised a relationship had fundamentally changed.
These moments carry weight because they're saturated with meaning, emotion, and sensory detail. They're crossroads where internal and external worlds collide.
The same principle applies to exceptional creative writing.
A full-mark Selective creative piece doesn't need to take readers on an epic journey. It needs to transport them completely into one meaningful moment and make them feel its full emotional impact.
Understanding The Selective Test Writing Marking Criteria
Before we dive into the step-by-step process, let's revisit what the Selective Test writing criteria actually rewards.
Remember, examiners are looking at Set A and Set B criteria:
Set A (Content and Structure) evaluates:
- Quality and originality of ideas
- Suitability of form and genre
- Clear, logical flow
- Effective structure
Set B (Language and Accuracy) evaluates:
- Deliberate style and vocabulary choices
- Appropriate formality
- Technical accuracy
- Use of figurative language
Notice what's NOT on this list? Complex plot structures. Multiple settings. Character backstories. Plot twists.
Markers value originality, depth, precise language, and emotional resonance.
A single, beautifully rendered moment allows you to excel in all these areas far more effectively than a rushed, complete narrative ever could.
The 3-Minute Strategy for Selective Writing Success
Here's the systematic approach I now teach all my students at NL English Academy. This is the same process that helped me achieve a band 6 in HSC English Advanced. Please note that planning in the Selective Test should take no longer than 3 minutes, so as soon as the clock starts ticking, plan ahead immediately. It is common to take longer than 3 minutes when you first start planning strategically, so this planning strategy must be practiced repeatedly over time to increase in efficiency and reduce how long you take.
Step 1: Choose a Universal Human Experience
Start by identifying the fundamental human experience at the heart of your piece. This becomes your thematic anchor.
The most powerful creative writing taps into experiences that transcend individual circumstances. These are the emotions and situations that every person, regardless of background, can connect with on some level.
Common universal experiences include:
- Loss and grief
- Belonging and isolation
- Discovery and revelation
- Change and transformation
- Identity and self-understanding
- Connection and disconnection
- Fear and courage
- Memory and forgetting
Here's the key: don't just pick a theme randomly. Consider which universal experience the prompt is inviting you to explore. Even the most unusual prompts can be approached through these fundamental human lenses.
For example, if the prompt asks you to write about "a door that should never have been opened," you might explore:
- Discovery (what was revealed)
- Change (how this moment altered everything)
- Loss (of innocence, safety, or certainty)
The universal experience you choose will guide every other decision in your writing.
Step 2: Find a Specific, Vivid Moment That Embodies This Theme
Once you've identified your universal theme, zoom in dramatically. Find the single moment where this theme becomes tangible and immediate.
This is where most students struggle, so let me give you concrete examples.
Instead of writing about loss in general, write about the moment a child realises their grandmother's chair will remain empty at dinner. Not the funeral. Not the weeks of grief afterward. Just that one dinner, that one empty chair.
Instead of writing about belonging, write about the moment a student hears their name pronounced correctly for the first time by a new teacher. Not their entire journey of cultural identity. Just that single moment of recognition.
Instead of writing about change, write about the moment someone notices their childhood home has been repainted a different color. Not their entire experience of growing up or moving away. Just that instant of confronting visible change.
The moment you choose should be:
- Specific enough to visualise clearly - Readers should be able to picture exactly where and when this is happening
- Brief enough to explore deeply - You need room to layer in detail, not rush through events
- Significant enough to carry emotional weight - The moment should feel like it matters, even if it seems small
Ask yourself: if you were filming this moment, what would the camera focus on? That tight focus is what you're aiming for in your writing.
Step 3: Layer It with Sensory Detail and Cultural Significance
This is where good creative writing becomes exceptional. You're not just describing what happens, you're building a world that readers can step into completely.
Sensory detail means engaging all five senses, not just sight. This is what makes your writing immersive rather than observational.
Instead of: "The kitchen was old."
Try: "The kitchen tiles had yellowed to the color of old teeth, and the air tasted of garlic and ginger that had seeped into the walls over decades."
Cultural significance adds layers of meaning that elevate your writing from personal to universal. This is what makes your specific moment resonate with readers who haven't lived your exact experience.
For instance, if you're writing about a family dinner, cultural significance might include:
- The specific foods that carry meaning in your culture
- Rituals around how meals are served or eaten
- Generational differences in language or customs
- Objects that hold cultural or family history
- These details do double duty: they make your writing more vivid AND more meaningful.
Here's a practical example of layering:
Basic version: "My grandmother's hands looked old as she cooked."
Layered version: "Ba's hands moved through the familiar rhythm - pinch, fold, pinch - shaping each dumpling with the muscle memory of sixty years. The thin skin of her knuckles had become translucent, showing the blue map of veins beneath, but her fingers never hesitated. This was the only recipe she'd never written down. 'Some things,' she'd say in Cantonese, 'live in the hands, not the head.'"
See the difference? The second version gives you visual detail (translucent skin, blue veins), action (pinch, fold), cultural context (Cantonese language, dumpling-making tradition), and thematic significance (knowledge passed through doing, not documenting).
This is something you must keep in the back of your mind when planning. Ask yourself - where can you layer your sentences and events with sensory detail? If you forget to anticipate or plan to do this, it’s quite likely you may overlook it entirely when you are under time pressure in the middle of writing.
Step 4: Show Internal Conflict or Realisation Within This Moment
Every powerful moment in creative writing contains some form of internal tension. This is what gives your writing depth and prevents it from being merely descriptive.
Internal conflict doesn't mean your character needs to be torn between two huge decisions. It means showing the complexity of human emotion - how we can feel multiple things simultaneously, or how a single moment can shift our understanding. This internal conflict can occur at the same time as an external conflict, but essentially, this section is the complication or climax.
Types of internal conflict that work well:
- Recognition vs. denial (knowing something is true but resisting it)
- Past vs. present (how memory conflicts with current reality)
- Expectation vs. reality (what should happen vs. what actually happens)
- Desire vs. duty (what we want vs. what we must do)
- Understanding vs. confusion (the moment clarity emerges or dissolves)
The key is to show this conflict subtly through your character's observations, reactions, and thoughts - not by stating it explicitly.
Weak approach: "I felt conflicted about leaving home."
Strong approach: "I'd packed the suitcase three times, each time finding one more thing that couldn't possibly be left behind. The ticket sat on my desk, one corner curling upward as if trying to escape. In two days, I'd be gone. In two days, this room would just be a room again, waiting for someone else's dreams to fill it. I picked up the ticket and pressed the corner flat."
The internal conflict is clear: the tension between leaving and staying, between moving forward and holding on - but it's shown through actions and observations rather than stated feelings.
Therefore, when planning what your complication or climax in creative writing should be, think about showing internal conflict in this moment of intensity as well.
Step 5: End with Emotional Resonance, Not Just A Resolution
Here's what separates memorable creative writing from forgettable creative writing: the ending.
Most students feel compelled to wrap everything up neatly. They want to tell readers what the moment meant, what changed, how things turned out.
But the best creative writing pieces continue to resonate with readers. It leaves readers with a feeling, an image, or a question that lingers after the final sentence.
Resolution means everything is explained and concluded. The reader knows exactly what happened and why it mattered.
Resonance means the ending echoes in the reader's mind. They're still thinking about it, feeling it, questioning it.
Techniques for creating resonance:
- Return to a sensory detail from earlier: "The chair remained empty. In the kitchen, the kettle began to whistle, shrill and insistent, but no one rose to quiet it."
- End with an image that carries symbolic weight: "She placed the letter back in the envelope, unopened. Outside, the first snow of winter had begun to fall."
- Leave the reader in the moment, not after it: "I reached for the door handle. My hand, I noticed, wasn't shaking anymore."
- Pose an implicit question: "The photograph showed a version of my mother I'd never known; young, laughing, unguarded. I wondered if she'd ever looked at me that way."
The ending should feel both inevitable (like this is where the moment naturally concludes) and open (like there's more happening just beyond what's written).
When planning your ending, think of how you can end your piece with a lasting taste that remains in the back of your marker’s mind. That’s how you make your piece memorable.
Selective Writing Example: From Stimulus to Full-Mark Plan
Let me show you how these five steps work in practice with a sample prompt:
Write a creative piece about a moment of unexpected discovery
- Step 1 - Universal experience: Discovery and revelation.
- Step 2 - Specific moment: A teenager finds an old photograph of their mother as a young woman, laughing with friends at a café, looking completely different from the tired parent they know today.
- Step 3 - Layering: The photograph's faded colours and creased edges, the unfamiliar lightness in their mother's expression, the vintage café setting with its checkered tablecloths, the handwritten date on the back in unfamiliar handwriting, the sound of their mother's footsteps approaching down the hallway.
- Step 4 - Internal conflict: The collision between seeing their mother as a separate person with her own history versus only knowing her in the role of "parent," shown through the character's careful examination of details in the photo - the carefree smile, the fashionable clothes, the youth - that seem impossible to reconcile with the person they see every day.
- Step 5 - Resonance: End with the character carefully placing the photograph back in the box, now aware they can never look at their mother the same way again, hearing her call their name from the kitchen.
Notice how this approach helps you plan to write a deep, meaningful content focused on one afternoon, one photograph, one realisation, rather than trying to cover the entire relationship or the whole experience of growing up and understanding parents differently. But again, it takes practice to think of these ideas under time pressure in under 3 minutes.
Common Mistakes In Selective Creative Writing
Even with this approach, students often fall into predictable traps. Here's what to watch for:
- Mistake 1: Explaining the significance. Don't tell readers "this moment changed everything" or "I finally understood." Show the change through what your character notices, does, or realises.
- Mistake 2: Including too many characters. A powerful moment usually focuses on one or two people. Additional characters dilute your focus and eat up precious word count.
- Mistake 3: Jumping between time periods. Stay in your moment. Resist the urge to include extensive flashbacks or flash-forwards. Brief references to the past or future can add depth, but your anchor should remain firmly in the present moment.
- Mistake 4: Using generic sensory details. "The sky was blue" or "it smelled good" don't create immersion. Be specific. What shade of blue? What did it smell like? Bread baking? Rain on hot concrete? Your grandmother's perfume?
- Mistake 5: Forcing figurative language. The marking criteria rewards figurative language, but it must feel organic. A clumsy metaphor is worse than a straightforward, precise description. Use similes and metaphors when they genuinely clarify or deepen your meaning.
- Mistake 6: A lack of exam technique. Many students will fall short because they are not efficient with their time in the exam. They either can’t type fast enough or can’t create a story quickly enough, meaning they lose precious marks. This is why it is so important for students to master touch typing and planning to save time in the exam.
The Importance of Practice
Understanding this approach intellectually is one thing. As mentioned earlier, applying it under exam conditions is another.
This is why regular practice is non-negotiable. Not just writing creative pieces, but specifically practicing this moment-focused approach.
Here's how to practice effectively:
- Weekly exercise: Take any prompt and spend 3 minutes identifying your universal theme, specific moment and your entire plan. This planning phase is what separates rushed writing from purposeful writing.
- Revision practice: Take a creative piece you've already written with a traditional story structure. Identify the single most powerful moment within it. Rewrite the entire piece focusing only on that moment with extensive detail.
- Sensory inventory: When you're in a real location - your classroom, the park, your kitchen - pause and catalogue everything you can perceive with all five senses. This trains your brain to notice details you can later use in writing.
- Read critically: When you read published short stories or full-mark creative pieces, identify exactly where the writer focuses their attention. Notice how often the best pieces live in a single moment or scene.
My Final Thoughts
When you stop trying to tell everything and instead commit to exploring one moment with depth, precision, and emotional honesty, your writing transforms. It becomes the kind of writing that examiners remember. The kind that scores full marks.
In the Selective Test, this planning approach will ensure you write conceptually with depth, whilst remaining short enough to complete within the tight time constraints of the writing section.
But more importantly, it helps your piece become the kind of writing that actually means something.
The best creative pieces linger in a reader's mind long after the final sentence. They create a moment so vivid and resonant that it becomes part of the reader's own emotional landscape.
So the next time you face a creative writing prompt, remember: you don't need to tell a whole story. You just need to capture one perfect moment and let it breathe.
Our students achieve top bands, cohort rankings & entry into their dream schools.
IMPORTANT: To maintain our success rates, term program admissions are strictly by application only. Only a handful of selected students are accepted.
As featured in...
We're proud to be the main sponsor of NSBHS Falcon Football Club.
© 2025 NL English Academy. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions |